First American Home Warranty Review

If you’re thinking about buying a home warranty, you may be considering First American Home Warranty, a leader in the industry.

Home warranties like First American’s can feel like a gamble. Will the warranty pay when you need it to? Or will you find out the hard way your warranty doesn’t cover the repair you need?

You may not know unless you comb through a warranty contract line by line, looking for exceptions, conditions, and requirements of you, the homeowner. So let’s take a close look at First American Home Warranty.

About First American Home Warranty

First American Home Warranty has been in business for almost 40 years and currently serves about 450,000 clients in 38 states.

That’s a substantial amount of customers and a wide range of coverage. Paired with more than three decades of service, the numbers speak highly for First American’s reputation. It’s one of the leading home warranty companies today.

But you also need to assess the terms of their home warranty policies and the types of claims they actually cover to make an informed decision.

Let’s go through the company’s warranties element by element:

What Does First American Home Warranty Cover?

First American has three plan categories: Starter, Essential, and Premium. Any prices quoted in this section could change without notice.

First American typically raises its premiums every few years. The company sells annual contracts but allows monthly payments.

Starter Plan

The Basic Plan ($42 a month) covers:

• Dishwasher

• Kitchen Refrigerator

• Kitchen Range Hood

• Microwave Oven (Built-In Only)

• Oven/ Range/ Cooktop

• Plumbing

• Plumbing Stoppages

• Toilet Tanks, Bowls and Mechanisms

• Electrical

• Ductwork

• Heating

• Refrigerant

Essential Plan

The Essential Plan ($52 a month) covers everything in the Basic Plan, plus:

• Clothes Washer and Dryer

• Trash Compactor

• Water Heater

• Fans (Attic, Exhaust, Ceiling, Whole House)

• Garage Door Opener

• Ductwork

• Heating

• Refrigerant

• Air Conditioning

• Mini-Split Ductless Systems

• Concrete Encasement

• HVAC Lifting Equipment

• Improper Installations / Modifications

• Permits and Code Violations

• Refrigerant Recapture, Reclaim, Disposal

• Air Conditioning

Premium Plan

The Premium Plan ($67 a month) covers everything in the Essential Plan, plus:

• Garbage Disposal

• Hose Bibbs

• Install Ground Level Cleanout

• Instant Hot Water Dispenser

• Shower Head and Shower Arm

• Garage Door Springs, Hinges, and Transmitters

• Central Vacuum System

• Registers, Grills, Filters

• Window AC Units

• Pre-season HVAC Tune-up

• Roof Coverage

Upgrades

Additional available upgrades to all plans include:

• Well Pump ($7.08 Extra per Month)

• Water Softener ($7.08 Extra per Month)

• Pool/Spa Equipment ($20.83 Extra per Month)

• Additional Refrigeration ($4.17 Extra per Month)

• Septic Tank Pumping / System ($7.08 Extra per Month)

How Much Will First American Home Warranty Pay?

To understand how much a warranty could pay, you have to consider payout caps and service fees.

When you contact your warranty company for service, the company will typically send out a technician to assess the situation. You’ll pay a service fee for this initial step, and you can think of the fee as a deductible.

With First American Home Warranty, the fee is $85 in most states, but it could be as high as $100. We looked at a contract from Texas, where customers currently would pay $75 per visit from a technician.

Assuming the repair or replacement you need will be covered by the warranty, your next concern will be the warranty’s payout cap. Again, these can vary from state to state.

Expense Caps

The contract for Texas is fairly typical for First American, and it caps payouts like this:

• Plumbing: $500 maximum per year for repairs to the pipes in your home.

• Water Heater: $1,500 maximum per year, excluding flues and vents and fuel storage areas.

• Kitchen Appliances: Limited to $3,500 per covered appliance.

• Heating System: Limited to $1,500 per year.

• Central Air Conditioning (Optional Add-on): limited to $1,500 per year.

Other systems in the First American Home Warranty contract do not cap expenses, but they have specific limits on what parts of the system the warranty will repair or replace.

Limitations

In these cases, the fine print can go on for a while, so the following lists aren’t all-inclusive. If you’d like to fully assess the details of a contract, you’ll need to go through the quote process and ask for a sample contract.

The following examples should give you a better idea of what to look for when you’re investigating a contract’s limitations:

• Electrical System: No expense cap, but the plan won’t pay for doorbells, alarm systems, intercoms, audio or video recording devices, damages due to power surges, or inadequate wiring capacity.

• Garage Door Openers: No expense cap, but the plan won’t pay for remote controllers, gate motors, hinges and springs, and side rails.

• Laundry Appliances: No expense cap, but the plan won’t pay for repairs to filter and lint screens, knobs and dials, venting, or damage to clothing.

These limitations are typical for a home warranty, and you’ll want to study the details carefully before signing up. If you think the contract won’t provide services you anticipate needing, don’t sign the contract.

Filing Warranty Claims

You will have to wait 30 days after signing the First American warranty contract before you’re eligible to file a claim.

After the waiting period, you can contact First American’s customer service staff any time of the day or night, either via phone or online to start a claim.

How to File a Claim

Starting the claims process online has the advantage of documenting your claim from the outset in case you need to dispute the company’s decision later.

If the customer service staff is certain your problem won’t be covered, the claims process can end immediately. But in most cases, the company will send out a home repair technician who will charge you the service fee we discussed earlier. The service charge is typically $85.

After you pay the service fee, the warranty technician should fix or arrange a replacement at no charge, up to the annual limits of the warranty. At this point, your warranty will either seem like a great idea or a waste of money, depending on the outcome of your claim.

Often, when a warranty does not pay a claim, the homeowner feels cheated, and understandably so. However, warranty companies like First American generally do not breach their own contracts, so knowing the intricacies of your contract can help you dispute an unpaid claim.

Common Reasons for Claims Denials

Here are some common and legitimate reasons a warranty could deny your claim for service:

• System Not Covered: When you buy a warranty and then renew it a couple of times, it’s easier than you might think to forget what coverage you bought, especially if your real estate agent helped purchase the initial warranty. A Starter Plan from American Home won’t cover your plumbing, for example, so if you filed a claim to fix a frozen pipe, you’d get an automatic denial. I know this is kind of like asking whether your computer’s plugged in when you call tech support. But there’s a reason people ask.

• Bill Not Paid: Sometimes, customers fall behind on their monthly bills and decide to skip a few warranty payments. If that happens and you need to file a claim, you’re giving the warranty company a reason to deny service.

• Contract Caps Met: American Home has more relaxed payout maximums than most other companies, but on many systems, the company still sets an annual maximum. This makes sense: A company wouldn’t stay in business if it regularly paid out more than you’re paying in premiums.

• Maintenance Standards Not Met: Again, American Home’s standards aren’t as high as many other companies, some of which require proof you’ve performed regular maintenance on your covered systems in order to get coverage. American Home will often require regular maintenance on larger items such as your central heat and air (if you opt into AC coverage). The company typically doesn’t require its own initial home inspection before you sign the contract.

How to Avoid Denied Claims

Getting a claim denial can be infuriating. You feel cheated, and you still have to figure out how to pay for the repair you need. Reading your contract carefully, line by line will help you know whether the warranty provider is living up to its agreement or whether you should file a claim.

Believe it or not, a denial may not be the worst experience you can have with a warranty company. You could get approved for service only to experience delays in service, making you feel stuck in between.

Or, you could get stuck in another in-between: a repair you’re not happy with that the warranty company insists has been completed.

Who Will First American Send to Help?

First American has its own staff of home repair technicians. If the company’s technicians need more expert help, they can bring in specialists of their choosing. Customers have little control over who comes out to repair their home system.

Although First American serves nearly half a million customers around the country, the company usually sends technicians from your general area.

This reduces waiting times, and it also helps the company adhere to your local codes.

However, the company will not send help specifically to get a system up to code. A warranty exists to replace or repair systems in your home, not to maintain them.

Grading First American Home Warranty

If you’re trying to decide whether to buy a warranty from First American Home Warranty, you’ll quickly discover it’s a tough question to answer.

What Customers Say

In many ways, the First American’s customer service rates better than other warranty companies:

• The Better Business Bureau gives the company a B+.

• TrustPilot, which compiles customer reviews, gives it 3.9 out of 5 stars.

These ratings result, in part, from First American’s commitment to dealing with complaints. But, individual customer reviews tell a different tale. Customers express frustration, annoyance, and disgust in review after review.

Of course, customer reviews tend to lean toward the negative. Happy customers are generally less compelled to share their feelings online. Still, this preponderance of frustration can’t be simply ignored.

Truth be told, it’s unfair to single out First American. Just about any home warranty company can inspire these feelings when the warranty doesn’t pay as the customer expected.

Alternatives

Do You Need a Home Warranty?

A warranty works kind of like home insurance, but instead of protecting you against loss of value from disasters such as fires and hurricanes, a warranty can shield you from out-of-control home repair costs.

When to Avoid a Home Warranty

• You Have a Healthy Savings Account: When you could afford to repair or replace major appliances or home systems if needed, you could have less need for a warranty.

• You Can Borrow Money Easily: When you have great credit and a low debt-to-income ratio, you can usually find no-interest loan offers for big repairs like HVAC systems or electrical wiring repairs.

• You Have a Brand New Home: The protection a warranty can provide makes the most sense with older homes, which could require expensive repairs at any point.

• You Have Other Protections in Place: Maybe most of your home’s systems already have manufacturer’s warranties or service contracts from the installation company.

• You’re Good at Fixing Things: Some people have the gift of fixing just about anything that breaks, meaning they’d be on the hook only for parts and their own time.

If any of the above scenarios describes your life, you could possibly get by without buying a warranty.

When to Buy a Home Warranty

On the other hand, if the following conditions describe your home and your financial life, you may want to consider a warranty more seriously:

• Several Major Systems in Your Home Are Old: An HVAC system will typically last 20 to 25 years. Smaller systems such as dishwashers, clothes washers and dryers, garage door openers, and stoves may last a decade or so. If you buy an older home with aging systems, a warranty can seem more appealing.

• Your Mortgage Payment Stretches Your Budget: If your house payment already takes 35 percent or more of your monthly income, a huge repair bill could spell financial disaster. A warranty may seem like a sensible precaution.

• You Don’t Have Much in Savings or Solid Credit: If you can’t spend or borrow your way out of a tight spot, a warranty can provide some extra peace of mind.

Someone with all of these limitations may be the most ideal candidate for a home warranty. But someone with a tight budget also has the most to lose by getting a warranty that doesn’t pay.

Bottom Line

Here’s the number one rule if you’re shopping for a home warranty: Read and understand every last word of the contract before signing up.

If you don’t understand part of the contract, get in touch with the company’s customer service staff to get answers to your questions.

Becoming an expert on your warranty contract will help prevent you from being surprised when the warranty won’t cover a repair you need.

Becoming an expert on the contract can also prevent you from buying a plan that doesn’t meet your home’s specific needs.

Home warranties like First American sell peace of mind. It’s up to you to find out whether the warranty would actually provide it.

How We Review Home Warranty Companies: 

Good Financial Cents evaluates home warranty companies by examining coverage breadth, responsiveness, and the reliability of claims processes. Our goal is to offer homeowners a balanced and informative perspective. Editorial transparency is a consistent focus in our reviews.

We actively gather information from home warranty companies, reviewing the specifics of coverage plans and service agreements. This data, paired with our research and customer feedback, informs our evaluation process. Companies are then rated based on their performance, leading to a star rating from one to five.

For further insight into the criteria we use to rate home warranty companies and our evaluation approach, please refer to our editorial guidelines and full disclaimer.